Tuesday, 7 June 2016

እነ ብርሃኑ ተ/ያሬድ መከላከል አትችሉም ተባሉ

የካቲት 4/2008 ዓ.ም ፌደራል ከፍተኛ ፍርድ ቤት ልደታ ምድብ 14ኛ ወንጀል በዋለው ችሎት እነ ብርሃኑ ተ/ያሬድ ( ብርሃኑ ተ/ያሬድ፣ እየሩሳሌም ተስፋው፣ ፍቅረማርያም አስማማው እና ደሴ ካህሳይ) አቃቢ ህግ ያቀረበባቸውን ክስ በሰነድና በአንድ የሰው ምስክር ማስረጃዎች አስረድቷል በሚል ተከሳሾች መከላከል ይገባቸዋል ሲል ፍርድ ቤቱ መወሰኑ ይታወሳል፡፡ ውሳኔውን ተከትሎም መከላከያ ማስረጃዎች ያቀርቡ ከሆነ በሚል ፍርድ ቤቱ ጠይቆ፣ ተከሳሾች 200 የሰው ምስክሮችና የሰነድ ማስረጃዎች በጋራ እንደሚያቀርቡ አሳውቀው ነበር፡፡ ከዛ በኋላ በነበሩ ቀጠሮዎችም ምስክሮቻቸውን በዝርዝር ያስገቡ ሲሆን ከዛሬ ግንቦት 30 እስከ ሰኔ 8 , 2008 ድረስ ምስክሮቻቸውን እንዲያሰሙ ቀጠሮ ተሰጥቷቸው የነበረ ቢሆንም የቀጠሯቸው ቀን ሳይደርስ ባለፈው ሳምንት ፍርድ ቤት ቀርበው ጭብጥ እንዲያሲዙ ተጠይቀዋል። እነሱም የምስክርነት ጭብጥ ምስክሮች መሃላ ሳይፈፅሙ መያዝ እንደሌለበት ለፍቤቱ አስረድተው ውሳኔውን ለመስማት ለዛሬ ተቀጥረው ነበር።

የዛሬው ውሳኔ ግን በጣም የሚደንቅ ነው። አራት ወር ሙሉ ፍርድ ቤቱ ሲሰጥ የነበረውን ትእዛዝ ይቃረናል። “መከላከያ ምስክር ማሰማት የለባችሁም ስለዚህ ለፍርድ ብይን ሃምሌ 13, 2008 ቅረቡ” የሚል ውሳኔ አስተላልፋለች ዳኛዋ።
 
 Mahlet Fantahun's photo.

Monday, 6 June 2016

የኖርዲክ ሃገራት ለአርበኞች ግንቦት ሰባት 2.42 ሚሊዮን ብር ለገሱ!!



በትላንትናዉ ለት 04/06/2016 በኖርዌይ ኦስሎ ከተማ በስካንዲክ ሃገራት የሚኖሩ የአርበኞች ግንቦት 7 አባላት ግብረሃይል አስተባባሪነት የአርበኞች ግንቦት 7 ለፍትህ፣ ለዲሞክራሲና፣ ለነፃነት በተደረገዉ የገቢ ማሰባሰቢያ ዝግጅት 800 ሺ የኖርዌጅያን ገንዘብ (2.42 ሚሊዮን ብር) ገቢ ተሰበሰበ። በዕለቱ ዝግጅት ፕሮፌሰር ብርሃኑ ነጋ ከኤርትራ ግንባር እንዲሁም ፕሮፌሰር ጌታቸዉ ኃይሌ በክብር እንግድነት የተገኙ ሲሆን የግንቦት 7 አመራር የነበረዉና በኢትዮጵያ መንግስት ከየመን ታፍኖ የተወሰደዉ አቶ አንድአርጋቸዉ ፅጌ እህት ወ/ሮ ብዙአየሁ ፅጌ ባልተጠበቀ ሁኔታ ከቦታዉ መገኘት ታዳሚዉን ከፍተኛ ስሜት ዉስጥ የከተተ ነበረ። በተለይም ወ/ሮ ብዙአየሁ በቦታዉ ላይ በመገኘት ያደረጉት ንግግርና ያቀረቡት ግጥም ታዳሚዉን በስሜት የናጠና አብዛኛዉን የእልህ እንባ ያስነባ ነበረ። የገቢ ማሰባሰብያዉን ዝግጅት ለመሳተፍ ከስዊድን የመጡ የድርጅቱ አባሎችና ደጋፊዎች ያቀረቡት በዝሙሮችና ጭፈራዎች የታዳሚዉን ቀልብ የሳቡ ነበሩ።

በዝግጅቱ መጀመሪያ ወደ መድረክ የተጋበዙት የስዊድን የአርበኞች ግንቦት 7 ሥራ አስፈፃሚ ሰብሳቢ የሆኑት አቶ ዘለሌ ሲሆኑ ለዝግጅቱ መሳካት የስዊድን ሥራ አስፍፃሚ አመራር ከኖርዌይ ግብረሃይል ጋር በመተባበር በጥምረት እንደሰሩት ገለፃ ያደረጉ ሲሆን አያይዘዉም በስዊድን ስቶክሆልም ለኢሳት ገቢ ማሰባሰቢያ ዝግጅት ላይ በተደረገዉ የስነፅሁፍ ዉድድር አሸናፊ በመሆን የሜዳሊያ ተሸላሚ የሆነዉ ወጣት ሜዳሊያዉን በኤርትራና በኢትዮጵያ ድንበር ለሀገራቸዉ ነፃነት ለሚታገሉ አርበኞች በስጦታነት እንዲረከብለት በአደራ የላከዉን የሜዳሊያ ሽልማት ለፕሮፌሰር ብርሃኑ ነጋ አስረክበዋል። በመቀጠል ወደመድረኩ የተጋበዙት ለፕሮፌሰር ጌታችዉ እስካሁን በኢትዮጵያዉስጥ ያለዉ አፈናና የኢኮኖሚ ዉድቀት ሂደት አደገኛና አስጊ ሁኔታ ዉስጥ መሆኑን በመግለፅ የወያኔን ስርዓት ማስወገድ አማራጭ የሌለዉ መፍትሄ መሆኑና በአሁን ሰዓት አርበኞች ግንቦት 7 እያደረገ ያለዉ ስልታዊ ትግል ትክክለኛ መፍትሄ መሆኑን በመግለፅ ሆሉም ኢትዮጵያዊ ይህንን ሃገርን የማዳን ጥሪ በመቀበል ወደ ትግበራ እንዲያመራ ጥሪያቸዉን አስተላልፈዋል በማያያዝም በኦሮሚያ እየተካሄደ ያለዉ ሕዝባዊ አንቢተኝነት የወያኔ አስከፊና ቅጥ የለሺ አገዛዝ ዉጤት መሆኑን በመግለፅ በአፀፋዉ ወያኔ አየወሰደ ያለዉን ኢሰብአዊ የኃይል እርምጃ ኮንነዋል የኦሮሞ ሕዝብ ጥያቄ ሁሉንም ኢትዮጵያዊ እንደሚያካትትም አያይዘዉ ገልፀዋል።

በመቀጠል ወደመድረክ የተጋበዙት በጉጉት ሲጠበቁ የነበሩት ፕሮፌሰር ብርሃኑ ነጋ ባደረጉት ንግግር በሚያደርጉት የትግል ሂደት ዉስጥ እንደ ፕሮፌሰር ጌታቸዉ አይነት ሰዉ ያለዉን የሞያና የእዉቀት ግብአት መሰረታዊ መሆናቸዉን ገልፀዉ የአርበኞች ግንቦት 7 ለፍትህ፣ ለዲሞክራሲና፣ ለነፃነት እየተከተለ ያለዉ የትግል ስርዓት የደቡብ አፍሪካ ጥቁሮች የአፓርታይድ ስርዓትን ለመደምሰስ የሄዱበት መንገድን እንደሚከተል በመግለፅ የአፓርታይድ ሰርዓት አሁን በኢትዮጵያ ካለዉ አገዛዝ ጋር የሚመሳሰልበትን ነጥቦች በመዘረዘር በጥልቀት ለታዳሚዉ አስረድተዋል በመቀጠልም የትግል ስልቱ ከዉጪ ሃገራት በሚደረግለት ተፋሰስ የሚደጎምና በዛ ላይ መሰረት ያደረገ ሳይሆን ከእያንዳንዱ ሃገር ወዳድ ኢትዮጵያዊ በሚደርግ ድጋፍ ትግሉ የዉጤት በር ድረስ የሚቀጥል መሆኑንም አበክረዉ ተናግረዋል አያይዘዉም ሁሉም ኢትዮጵያዊ ከአስከፊዉ የወያኔ ስርዓት በቶሎ ለመላቀቅ ከመቸዉም ግዜ በበለጠ መልኩ አብዝቶና አምርሮ እንዲታገል ጥሪአቸዉን አቅርበዋል።

የምግብ እረፍት በመስጠት የተጀመረዉ የጨረታ ዝግጅት ከፍተኛ ፉክክር የተካሄደበት ሲሆን ነዋሪነታቸዉን በኖርዌይ በርገን ከተማ ያደረጉ አርበኞች ከስዊድን የግንባሩ አባላት ጋር ያደረጉት ፉክክር ቀልብን የሳበ ነበረ፤ በመቀጠልም ኢካደፍ(ኢትዮጵያን ከረንት አፌርስ)በኩል ጨረታዉን ለመዉሰድ የተደረገዉ ዉድድር እጅግ በጣም አስደሳች የነበረ ሲሆን ሌላዉ ማህበረሰብም የነበረዉ ተሳትፎ እጅግ የሚያኮራ ነበረ በስተመጨረሻም የአቶ አንድአርጋቸዉ ፅጌ እህት ወ/ሮ ብዙአየሁ ፅጌ ለጨረታ የቀረበዉን ምስል በ ከፍተኛዉን ገንዘብ በግለሰብ በመክፈል በማሸነፍ ሽልማቱን ለኖርዌይ የአርበኞች ግንቦት 7 አባላት ያበረከቱ ሲሆን የኖርዌይ የአርበኞች ግንቦት 7 ተወካይ ስእሉን ለስዊድን ግንቦት 7 አባላት በስጦታነት አስረክበዋል።

በስተመጨርሻም ዝግጅቱ ሰፋ ላለ የዉይይት መድረክ ክፍት በማደረግ በዝግጅቱ ላይ የታደሙት ማህበረሰቦች ፕሮፌሰር ብርሃኑ ነጋ ጋር በአርበኞች ግንቦት 7 ለፍትህ ለዲሞክራሲና ለነፃነት የትግል ስርዓትና ሂደት በዝርዝር በመወያየት ዝግጅቱ ተጠናቋል።


Saturday, 4 June 2016

Ethiopia: Detainees beaten and forced to appear before court inadequately dressed

(Amnesty International)— Authorities in Ethiopia should immediately stop the ill treatment of political opposition members and human rights defenders who were beaten in detention and then forced to appear before the court inadequately dressed, Amnesty International said today.

Amnesty International Report 2015/16 - Ethiopia

The 22 defendants, including political opposition leaders Gurmesa Ayano and Beqele Gerba, Deputy Chief of the Oromo Federalist Congress, were brought today before the court inadequately dressed. According to complaints lodged with the court by Beqele Gerba, some defendants were beaten while in detention, and prison officials confiscated all the defendant’s black suits, which they intended to wear to court. The rest of their clothes were taken by other prisoners.

“Aside from the beatings they suffered in detention, degrading the defendants by making them attend court in their underpants is a new low in the behavior of the prison authorities and a total outrage,” said Michelle Kagari, Amnesty International’s Deputy Director for Eastern Africa and the Great Lakes.

“The Ethiopian authorities and the Court cannot let this ill-treatment go unanswered. They must ensure a prompt credible investigations and that those responsible are held accountable.”

The 22 defendants were charged under the Anti-terrorism Proclamation law for organizing the November 2015 Oromia protest. On April 26, 2016 the court adjourned their hearing for May 11, 2016. However on May 11 the prison authorities failed to present the defendants in court. The defendants all wore black suits in mourning for those killed during the protests, which apparently caused the prison authorities to refuse to take them to court.

“Ethiopia’s long time muzzling of dissent has had a devastating effect on opposition members and human rights defenders who are completely prevented from exercising their right to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly,” said Kagari.

Beqele Gerba and the co-defendants in the case were arbitrarily arrested following the largely peaceful protests which began in November 2015 against the dispossession of land without adequate compensation in Ethiopia’s Oromo region.

In response to the protests, the authorities arbitrarily arrested thousands of people, and several hundreds of people participating in the protests have been unlawfully killed by the security services.

Friday, 3 June 2016

Police brings Bekele Gerba et.al to court barefoot, wearing only shorts and t-shirts

The Addis Abeba prison administration Qilinto prison police have this morning brought prominent opposition figure Bekele Gerba and the 21 others in the same file for a hearing at a court all barefoot. The detainees were also wearing mere shorts and t-shirts when they appeared at the Federal High Court 19th Criminal Bench here in the capital.

Bekele Gerba with barefoot
Bekele Gerba

Once inside the court room the detainees, through Bekele Gerba, first secretary general of the opposition Oromo Federalist Congress (OFC), told the judges that the police have come to their cells in Qilinto, a prison in the outskirt of south of Addis Abeba, yesterday and stripped them all of their clothes and shoes to prevent them from wearing black upon appearing in court this morning.

On May 11 the police have failed to bring the 22 detainees, all charged with Ethiopia’s infamous Anti-Terrorism Proclamation, ATP, to the court because all them were wearing black to protest their arrest.  However, the police have told the court this morning that they didn’t bring defendants during the last hearing because they have not received a letter from the court.  The judge told the police at the court this morning that the police officers on duty on May 11 must appear in court to explain the real reason.

Bekele also told the court that he and his co-defendants were subjected to torture and other forms of physical and psychological abuses inside the prison and requested the judge for a change of prison. But the judge denied the request.

The 22 defendants were all arrested between November and December 2015, shortly after the start (and in connection with) Oromo protests in November that gripped the nation for the next five months. Defendants include several members of OFC, students and civil servants who came from various parts of the Oromia regional state.

Prosecutors have charged the 22 with various articles of the ATP. The charges include, but not limited to, alleged membership of the banned Oromo Liberation Front (OLF), public incitement, encouraging violence, as well as causing the death of innocent civilians and property destructions in cities such as Ambo and Adama, 120km west and 100km east of Addis Abeba during the recent Oromo protests in Ethiopia. This morning all of the defendants have presented a written defense statement. The court adjourned the next hearing until June 27.

In a related development, the police at Qilinto have failed to bring this morning 16 other individuals, all from the Oromia regional state and were detained in connection with the #OromoProtests, to the court.  The 16 detainees, under the file name of Tesema Regasa were first brought to the court on April 26. They were subsequently charged with the ATP and have, last month, presented their defense statements to the court. Today’s court appearance was adjourned to hear prosecutors’ counter response for the defense statements. The court re-adjourned the next hearing until June 15.
Wondimu Ebbissa, who is representing Bekele Gerba et.al, said last month that more than 80 defendants, including Bekele Gerba et al, were held in Qilinto and a further 97 were believed to be either at  the Ethiopian Federal Polcie Force Central Bureau of Criminal Investigation, known in Amharic as Ma’ekelawi,  or the Addis Abeba police prison facility near it. All of them are detained in connection with #OromoProtests.

In a separate development, the Federal High Court 19th Criminal Bench yesterday adjourned the hearing for Yonatan Tesfaye, former spokesman of the opposition Semayawi (Blue) Party, until June 21. The court received Yonatan’s defense statement in its hearing and adjourned the next hearing to receive prosecutor’s counter statement.

Yonatan Tesfaye of Blue Pary

Last month prosecutors have charged Yonatan with ATP and have presented as evidence the defendant’s Facebook status updates during the #OromoProtests. The charges against Yonatan allege that he was posting inciting message on his Facebook, encouraging protesters to loot and destruct properties. Charges also allege Yonatan was calling for regime change  through violence.

Thursday, 2 June 2016

Ethiopia: End use of counter-terrorism law to persecute dissenters and opposition members

The Ethiopian Government must end its escalating crackdown on human rights defenders, independent media, peaceful protestors as well as members and leaders of the political opposition through the Anti-Terrorism Proclamation (ATP) says a group of civil society organisations (CSOs).
“The government’s repression of independent voices has significantly worsened as the Oromo protest movement has grown,” said Yared Hailemariam, Director of the Association for Human Rights in Ethiopia (AHRE). “The international community should demand the end of this state-orchestrated clampdown and the immediate release of peaceful critics to prevent the situation from deteriorating further.”

The recent escalation in the use of the ATP to prosecute peaceful protesters, journalists, bloggers, human rights defenders, and opposition leaders and members is indicative of the Ethiopian Government’s growing intolerance of dissent. Largely peaceful protests began in November 2015 against the dispossession of land without adequate compensation in the Oromia region. In response to the protests, the Ethiopian authorities have arbitrarily arrested thousands of people and several hundred people have been summarily killed by the security services while participating in the protests.

While the bulk of those arrested since February 2016 have not been charged, several are currently being prosecuted under the ATP. These include Getachew Shiferaw (Editor-in-Chief of the online newspaper Negere Ethiopia), Yonathan Tesfaye Regassa (former head of public relations for the opposition Semayawi Party), Bekele Gerba (Deputy Chair, Oromo Federalist Congress (OFC)) and Dejene Tufa (Deputy General Secretary, OFC) and Gurmesa Ayana (secretary, OFC). Fikadu Mirkana, (news editor and a reporter with the public Oromia Radio and TV), was arrested on 19 December 2015, charged under the ATP and released five months later in April 2016.

Getachew was held in Maekelawi Detention Centre after his arrest on 25 December 2015. On 22 April 2016, upon reaching the four-month limit for investigations permissible under the ATP, the court ordered the Federal Police to close the investigation. Yet Getachew remained in police custody and on 23 May was charged under the ATP. He has since been moved to the Kilinto detention centre.
“The Ethiopian government is using laws and judicial processes that fail to meet international human rights standards to harass and stifle dissent, targeting activists, human rights defenders, opposition party leaders and journalists ” said Haben Fecadu, Campaigner at Amnesty International.

Despite repeated calls from CSOs, independent UN experts, the European Parliament, and numerous governments, including the United States, the Ethiopian authorities continue to arbitrarily detain and prosecute scores of peaceful protestors for exercising their rights, using the broad provisions of the ATP to criminalise peaceful expressions of dissent. Since the enactment of the ATP in 2009, human rights defenders, journalists, bloggers and peaceful protestors have been prosecuted and convicted under its provisions.

“The international community – including the United Nations – should unconditionally condemn the arbitrary arrest and detention of human rights defenders in Ethiopia,” said Hassan Shire, Executive Director of DefendDefenders (East and Horn of Africa Human Rights Defenders Project). “The Ethiopian government’s use of counter-terrorism as a smokescreen to target the peaceful work of human rights defenders is an affront to its regional and international obligations.”

Most recently, on 10 May 2016, blogger Zelalem Workagenehu was sentenced to five years and four months in prison under the ATP. Zelalem, who works for the independent diaspora blog, De Birhan, was convicted under charges of conspiring to overthrow the government and supporting terrorism under the ATP. The activities on which these charges were based included organising a digital security training course and reporting on the peaceful protest movements in the country. Though the Federal High Court acquitted some of his co-defendants on 15 April 2016, the police re-arrested two of them only hours after they were released from Kilinto Prison on 17 April 2016 and detained them at Maekelawi Prison for a night. Yonathan Wolde and Bahiru Degu were charged with applying to participate in the same training, described by the government as “training to terrorise the country,” and of being members of Ginbot 7, a banned Ethiopian opposition party, which they deny.

Zelalem and Bahiru described for the trial court their conditions of and treatment in detention. Zelalem said he was detained in “Siberia” in the central Maekelawi Prison in Addis Ababa and was tortured by interrogators.

“Independent civil society and media is being quashed out of existence in Ethiopia,” said Tor Hodenfield, Policy and Advocacy Officer at CIVICUS. “The international community must call for more than tokenistic releases of human rights defenders and encourage the Ethiopian government to support avenues of peaceful dissent.”

Several members and leaders of opposition political parties have also been targeted under the ATP. Bekele Gerba and 21 other individuals were arrested on 23 December 2016, and charged under the ATP. They were then held for a four-month long investigation without access to their lawyer. Authorities transferred them to Kilinto Detention Centre on 22 April 2016. On 11 May 2016, the Prison Administration declined to bring the defendants to Lideta Federal High Court since all the defendants wore black suits, in expression of their mourning for the people killed during the protests. On 4 May 2016, former Spokesperson of the opposition Semayawi (Blue) Party, Yonathan Tesfaye Regassa, was charged with “incitement, planning, preparation, conspiracy and attempt” to commit a terrorism related act under the ATP.

On 25 April 2016, the Federal High Court sentenced the former Governor of Gambella Region, Okello Akway Ochalla, to nine years imprisonment under the ATP. Okello fled Ethiopia after the 2003 massacre in the region, and obtained Norwegian citizenship. He was arbitrarily arrested in South Sudan in March 2014 and handed over to Ethiopian security forces. He was originally charged under the ATP. The trial of Okello and his co-defendants was marred by violations of fair trial guarantees and including the use of witness testimonies in exchange for non-prosecution under the ATP.

The undersigned CSOs demand the competent Ethiopian authorities to take the necessary steps to bring the ATP in line with its international, regional and constitutional human rights obligations and immediately and unconditionally release all human rights defenders, journalists, bloggers and opposition party leaders and members imprisoned for peacefully exercising their rights.
  • Amnesty International
  • Article 19
  • Association for Human Rights in Ethiopia (AHRE)
  • CIVICUS: World Alliance for Citizen Participation
  • Civil Rights Defenders
  • Defend Defenders (East and Horn of Africa Human Right Defenders Project)
  • Ethiopia Human Rights Project (EHRP)
  • Front Line Defenders
  • International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH)

Wednesday, 1 June 2016

Petition launched against Tedros Adhanom’s WHO candidacy

Oppose Tedros Adhanom’s candidacy for Director-General of WHO

Click here to sign the Petition 

Tedros Adhanom, a politburo member of the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF)

Tedros Adhanom, a politburo member of the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) that has been ruling Ethiopia for the last 25 years is in the inner circle of the regime well known for its systematic patterns of political repression and egregious human rights violations against Ethiopian citizens. The abysmal human rights record of the Ethiopian regime is very well documented by all the major international rights groups (Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and Freedom House) as well as by the U.S. State Department in its annual human rights report.

In 2008, under his watch at the Federal Ministry of Health (2005-2012) there was a major cholera outbreak in Ethiopia’s Oromia Region. As a result of the deliberate inaction of Dr. Adhanom, the preventable and treatable outbreak tragically claimed many lives. Dr. Adhanom’s tenure as head of the Federal Ministry of Health was fraught with mismanagement and gross incompetence particularly as it relates to the monies (USD 1,306,035,989) granted from the Global Fund to Fight AIDS Tuberculosis and Malaria (GFATM).

The audit by the Office of the Inspector General into the USD 1,306,035,989 allocated to Ethiopia found: 1) misappropriation of funds and use of donor funds for unsound and politically motivated programs, 2) substandard quality of constructed health facilities and 3) ineligible expenditures. It was the recommendation of the OIG that the Ethiopian government should refund USD 7,026,929 to the Global Fund.  To this day, no action  has been taken  by the Ethiopian government to refund the money.

The candidate for Director General of a prestigious organization such as the WHO should not only be a person of high personal achievement but should also embody the highest adherence to internationally recognized human rights standards. Dr. Adhanom’s record as one of the leaders of the ruling party in Ethiopia and specifically his record as Minister of Health does not meet the exceedingly high standards required for a Director General of the WHO.

እነብርሀኑ ተ/ያሬድ ያለቀጠሮአቸው ተገደው ፍርድ ቤት ቀረቡ

--ፍርድ ቤቱ የተከሳሾችን የመከላኪያ ምስክሮች በምን ጭብጥ የሚሉትን እንዲናገሩ ከምስክሮቹ ቀጠሮ አስቀድሞ እንዲገለፁ ጠይቋል፡፡
--ተከሳሾቹ ፍርድ ቤቱ እና ማረሚያ ቤት ህገወጥ ጫናና ወከባ እየፈጠሩብን ይገኛል ብለዋል፡፡

የክስ መዝገባቸው በከፍተኛ ፍርድ ቤት ልደታ ምድብ 14ኛ ወንጀል ችሎት በመታየት ላይ የሚገኘው 4 ተከሳሾች ብርሀኑ ተ/ያሬድ እየሩሳሌም ተስፋው-ፍቅረማርያም አስማማው እና አቶ ደሴ ፍርድ ቤቱ እንዲከላከሉ ብይን በመስጠት የመከላከያ ምስክር ለማቅረብ ከግንቦት 30-ሰኔ 8 ቀጠሮ ተይዞላቸው የነበረ ቢሆንም ዛሬ ግንቦት 23 ቀን 2008ዓም ያለቀጠሮአቸው ፍርድ ቤት እንዲቀርቡ ተደርገዋል፡፡

ተከሳሾቹ ዛሬ የፍርድ ቤት ቀጠሮ እንደሌላቸው ለማረሚያ ቤቱ ሀላፊዎች ቀድመው ከግቢ የገለፁ ቢሆንም ማረሚያ ቤቱ የጥበቃ ሃላፊዎች መቅረብ አለባችሁ በሚል ግዳጅ ወከባና ግፍተራ እንዲቀርቡ መገደዳቸው ለፍ/ቤቱ ሲገልፁ ለማወቅ ተችሏል፡፡ ተከሳሾቹ ፍርድ ቤት ከቀረቡ በኃላ የፍርድ ቤቱም ዳኛም “ዛሬ ቀጠሮ ባይኖራችሁም ፍርድ ቤቱ ማጣራት ያለበት ጉዳይ ስላለ ነው የጠራናችሁ”በማለት የተከሳሾቹ መከላከያ ምስክሮች የሚመሰክሩበትን ጭብጥ ተከሳሾቹ ለፍርድ ቤቱ እንዲያስረዱ ተጠይቀዋል፡፡ 

ቀደም ሲል ተከሳሾቹ ካስብት የመከላኪያ ምስክሮች ከ1-10 ከፍተኛ የመንግስት ኃላፊዎች መሆናቸው ይታወቃል፡፡የምስክሮቹ ጭብጥ ማሳወቅ የሚገባን ምስክረነት በሚሰጥበት ዕለት እንጂ ምስክሮቹ ከመቅረባቸው አስቀድሞ ለፍርድ ቤቱ የማሳወቅ ህጋዊ ግዴታ የሌለባቸው መሆኑን ተከሳሾቹ የገለፁ ሲሆን ፍርድ ቤቱ እየጠየቀ ያለው ቅድመ ሁኔታ ግን ህጋዊ መሰረት የሌለው እና የፍርድ ቤቱም ተኃማኒነት የት ድረስ እንደሆነ ያሳያል፡፡ የፍትህ ስርዓቱ አይን ያወጣ የገዢው ፓርቲ የአፈና መዋቅር ተፅኖ እንዳረፈበት በግልፅ የሚያሳይ ብለውታል፡፡.ተከሳሾቹ አያይዘው እንደገለፁት ለምስክሮች የተዘጋጀው መጥሪያ በፍርድ ቤቱ ዳኛ ተፈርሞ ለምስክሮቻቸው እንዲሰጥ ማረሚያ ቤቱ ለሚገኙ ተከሳሾች ከደረሳቸው በኃላ በድጋሚ “በፍርድ ቤት ትእዛዝ ነው” በሚል ምክንያት መጥሪያዎቹ የተነጠቁ መሆኑ በማረሚያ ቤቱ ሀላፊዎች በኩልም መከላከያ ምስክሮቻቸው እንዳይቀርቡ እየተደረገ ሲሆን
የገዢው ፓርቲ ከፍተኛ ባለስልጣናት ለምስክርነት ማስጠራታቸውን ተከትሎ እንዲሰርዙ ማስፈራርያና ወከባ እየደረሰባቸው መሆኑ አያይዘው ገልፀዋል፡፡ 


በመጨረሻም ተከሳሾቹ የምስክሮቻቸውን ጭብጥ ለፍርድ ቤቱ እንደማያሳውቁ በአፅኖት የገለፁ ቢሆንም የፍርድ ቤቱ ዳኛ “ከአነጋገራችሁ የምስክሮቹን ጭብጥ ለመረዳት ችለናል በመሆኑም ይህንኑ ጉዳይ መርምረን ለግንቦት 30-2008 ብይን እንሰጥበታለን “ በማለት ለተከሳሾቹ በደፈናው ትህዛዝ በመስጠት ተመልሰዋል።